Did Atlanta Happen to You? Click Here for a Free Case Evaluation
Personal Injury Glossary

Directed Verdict

Definition
A directed verdict is a ruling in which the judge decides a case or an issue without sending it to the jury because the evidence, with every reasonable inference, could support only one outcome.

Juries decide disputed facts. When the evidence on a point is so one-sided that no reasonable jury could disagree, there is nothing to decide, and the judge can direct the result.

It is requested by motion during trial, usually after the other side rests or after all the evidence is in.

Defendants raise it most often, arguing the plaintiff failed to prove an element, but a plaintiff can move for one on liability too.

When A Judge Can Direct A Verdict

Georgia’s standard is in O.C.G.A. § 9-11-50(a). A verdict may be directed when there is no conflict in the evidence as to any material issue and the evidence, with all reasonable deductions, demands a particular verdict.

The motion may be made at the close of the evidence offered by an opponent, and an order granting it takes effect without any assent of the jury.

The judge does not weigh credibility. Every inference is drawn for the party opposing the motion, so any genuine conflict in the evidence sends the question to the jury.

Directed Verdict Versus Summary Judgment And JNOV

Summary judgment asks the same basic question before trial, on paper. A directed verdict asks it during trial, on the evidence actually presented.

If the motion is denied and the jury returns a verdict, the losing party may renew it as a motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict, filed under § 9-11-50(b) within 30 days after entry of judgment.

Either ruling can be reviewed on appeal under the same standard.

Directed Verdict Terminology In Georgia, Alabama, And South Carolina

Georgia keeps the traditional name. Its statute speaks of a motion for a directed verdict and a motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict.

Alabama renamed it. Alabama Rule of Civil Procedure 50 calls it judgment as a matter of law, granted when there is no legally sufficient evidentiary basis for a reasonable jury to find for a party on an issue.

South Carolina’s Rule 50 still uses directed verdict and allows one when the case presents only questions of law. The names differ, but each asks whether a jury question remains.

In Short

Directed Verdict: The Key Points

  • A directed verdict takes a question away from the jury when the evidence allows only one answer.
  • O.C.G.A. § 9-11-50(a) requires no conflict in the evidence on any material issue.
  • The judge draws every reasonable inference for the party opposing the motion.
  • A denied motion can be renewed after the verdict as a JNOV motion within 30 days.
  • Alabama calls the same ruling judgment as a matter of law.
  • South Carolina keeps the directed verdict name.
Common Questions

Directed Verdict: Questions Clients Ask

What is the difference between a directed verdict and summary judgment?

Timing. Summary judgment is decided before trial on documents and sworn statements. A directed verdict is decided during trial on the evidence actually presented.

Can a plaintiff get a directed verdict in a personal injury case?

Yes, usually on liability when the defendant’s fault is undisputed. Damages are almost always left to the jury.

What happens if a directed verdict is granted against me?

Judgment is entered for the other side on that claim or issue. The ruling can be appealed.

Google Reviews

Client Reviews: Getting Help With Directed Verdict

Watch

Learn How The Wilson PC Handles Directed Verdict

See how our attorneys fight for personal injury victims.

Free Consultation

Get Answers About Directed Verdict From The Wilson PC

Our personal injury attorneys have spent 20+ years fighting for accident victims across Georgia. Your consultation is free, and you pay nothing unless we win.

20+ Years of ExperienceNo Win, No FeeFree Case Review