Did Atlanta Happen to You? Click Here for a Free Case Evaluation
Personal Injury FAQ

Will Filing A Car Accident Claim Raise My Insurance Rates?

Quick Answer
Generally no — if you were not at fault, filing a claim against the at-fault driver’s insurance should not raise your own rates for that accident, and Georgia insurers generally cannot surcharge you for a not-at-fault crash. At-fault accidents are a different story. When in doubt, confirm with your insurer or agent.

One of the most common reasons people hesitate after a crash is fear of higher premiums. They assume that filing any claim will make their insurance rates jump, so they quietly absorb the cost of an accident someone else caused.

That fear is often misplaced. When you were not at fault, the rules generally work in your favor — and skipping a valid claim can leave real money and medical coverage on the table.

Understanding how your premiums actually respond to a claim helps you make the right call. A Georgia car accident lawyer can also help you pursue the at-fault driver’s insurance so the costs fall where they belong.

A Not-at-Fault Claim Generally Should Not Raise Your Rates

If another driver caused the crash, the claim is typically made against their liability insurance, not yours. Filing that third-party claim should not cause your own premiums to rise for the accident.

On top of that, Georgia insurers generally cannot surcharge you — that is, add a penalty to your premium — for an accident that was not your fault. The surcharge mechanism is aimed at at-fault drivers, not victims.

In other words, being hit by someone else is usually not a reason for your own carrier to raise your rate. The system is designed to let the at-fault driver’s insurer bear the loss.

Using Your Own MedPay or UM Coverage

Sometimes you have to use your own coverage even when you were not at fault — for example, medical payments coverage for early bills, or uninsured motorist coverage when the at-fault driver has none.

Using these coverages when you were not at fault also should not, by itself, be a basis for a surcharge. You paid for that protection precisely so it would be there when someone else hurt you.

That said, insurer practices vary, so it is reasonable to review your policy or ask your agent how a particular coverage is treated before you rely on it.

When Your Rates Can Actually Go Up

Rates can be affected when you are the at-fault driver. An accident you caused may count against you and lead to a higher premium at renewal, which is a normal part of how risk-based pricing works.

Other factors unrelated to fault — like changes in your area’s claim trends, your vehicle, or your overall driving record — can also move premiums over time. A single not-at-fault claim, by contrast, generally should not be the trigger.

If your rate does change after a not-at-fault accident, it is worth asking your insurer to explain why, since a not-at-fault claim alone should not be the reason.

Don’t Skip a Valid Claim Out of Fear

Many people wrongly walk away from a legitimate claim because they assume their premiums will spike. That can mean paying out of pocket for injuries and damage that the at-fault driver’s insurance should cover.

If you are unsure how a claim will affect your specific policy, the safest step is to confirm directly with your insurer or agent before deciding. They can tell you how your premium is calculated and whether a given claim counts against you.

Understanding the basics of how coverage responds after a crash makes this easier. See our overview of how car insurance works after an accident for the bigger picture.

In Short

Key Takeaways

  • If you were not at fault, filing a claim generally should not raise your rates for that accident.
  • Georgia insurers generally cannot surcharge you for a not-at-fault accident.
  • Using your own MedPay or UM coverage when you were not at fault generally should not trigger a surcharge.
  • Insurer practices vary, so check your policy or ask your agent about a specific coverage.
  • Rates can be affected by accidents you cause, and by factors unrelated to a single claim.
  • Don’t skip a valid claim out of fear — confirm the impact with your insurer first.
Common Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

Will my rates go up if the other driver was at fault?

Generally no. When you were not at fault, the claim is typically against the other driver’s insurer, and Georgia insurers generally cannot surcharge you for a not-at-fault accident.

Does using my own MedPay or UM coverage raise my premium?

Using your own coverage when you were not at fault generally should not be a basis for a surcharge. Practices vary, though, so it is wise to confirm with your insurer or agent.

When will a car accident actually raise my insurance rates?

Rates can be affected when you are the at-fault driver, since an accident you caused may count against you at renewal. A single not-at-fault claim generally should not be the trigger.

Should I avoid filing a claim to keep my rates low?

Usually not. Many people wrongly skip a valid claim out of fear of higher premiums and pay out of pocket for someone else’s fault. Confirm the impact with your insurer before deciding.

Google Reviews

What Our Clients Say

Watch

Learn More About The Wilson PC

See how our attorneys fight for personal injury victims in Georgia.

Free Consultation

Injured in Georgia? The Wilson PC Can Help.

Our personal injury attorneys have spent 20+ years fighting for accident victims across Georgia. Your consultation is free, and you pay nothing unless we win.

20+ Years of ExperienceNo Win, No FeeFree Case Review